This beer is older than our last blog post. Not a good sign.

Late February is not the best time of year to live in the northeastern United States. Days are brutish and short. Weather conditions fluctuate wildly; winter storms Magnus and Nemo rain terror upon the morning commuters. You must shovel, and salt. Football is over for five months. Joe Flacco and Ray Lewis are national heroes. Dark times, indeed.

But all is not lost, for you are a beer drinker! February means Hopslam. It means Nugget Nectar and Palate Wrecker. It means bushels of Nugget, Simcoe, Citra, and Columbus packed into this year’s iterations of highly anticipated seasonal offerings from the nation’s best breweries. Depending where you live, these beers are snatched up by thirsty consumers within a few weeks, and often the very same day they are unloaded from the distributor’s truck. On the far coast, Vinnie and Natalie from Russian River feted by the California state legislature beneath the banner: Welcome! Pliny the Younger; hopped, fermented sugar water transcends beverage to become celebrated American institution!

It’s no secret that the utilization of flavor and aroma hops fuel the craft beer explosion in the US. According to RateBeer, nearly 1 of every 10 new beers introduced in 2012 was IPA. And why not? As a beer consumer, once you’ve acquired the taste, a hopbomb always sounds good. I’ve convinced myself that IPA is the ideal beer style to pair with sushi, Mexican food, and barbecue. Is this because the citric/ floral/ coniferous flavors match objectively with raw fish or rice and beans? Naw, I’ve just rationalized a way to enjoy my favorite beers with my favorite foods. I’m an inveterate hophead.

But once you’ve contracted the hoplust, you have a problem on your hands. When the largest grocer in Pittsburgh, Giant Eagle, finally circumvented draconian PA liquor laws through licensing and began to sell beer in stores, I was elated. GE entering the beer market presented Pennsylvania consumers with an economic option between distributors which sold affordable beer but only by the case, and the specialty bottle shops which sold singles and six-packs at dramatically inflated prices. So Giant Eagle’s prices were good, and the selection was surprisingly excellent. But a few years into the experiment, I’ve noticed a disappointing trend- a lot of old beer sitting on the shelves. And a lot of these are IPA’s.

Let’s consider Founder’s Brewing, an Aleheads staple. No argument, one of the top breweries in the world and a personal favorite of mine. Everything they make is solid. Much of it is best-in-style. Some of it approaches the sublime. Giant Eagle purchases a sizable chunk of the Founder’s beers coming into Pittsburgh. The seasonal/ specialties like Fresh-hopped Ale, Backwoods Bastard, and Breakfast Stout fly off the shelves. KBS is always gone the same day- likewise the large format crazy stuff like Bolt Cutter, CBS, etc. Which is great. Pay attention to their release schedule and you have a decent shot of getting these beers at a fair price without waiting in line or paying a heavy premium at a specialty bottleshop.

Unfortunately to get all these rarities, Giant Eagle also buys a lot of Founders year-round beers. Now don’t get me wrong, I love Centennial IPA. When fresh, it stands with any IPA in the country. Their Dry-hopped Pale Ale is a delicate, delicious beer- but it needs to be consumed right away. As the hop oils begin to degrade, a variety of off-flavors emerge. To me, a lot of past-it pale ales take on  a cloying orange marmalade taste. Not good.

It’s not as big a deal when we’re talking about their Porter. I’d take Dirty Bastard with me into a zombie shelter and happily drink it for months. The shelf life on these is much longer, the effects of hop degradation less damaging. But the hoppy pale ales drop off a cliff after sitting too long, often not refrigerated.

I don’t mean to pick on Founders. I see it with every brewery. Store shelves also have in-state Victory Hop Wallop and Troeg’s Hop Back Amber well past their best. Twenty dollar six-packs of Ballast Point Sculpin, arguably the best IPA out there, sit for months. They have New Holland Hopivore and $25 bottles of Nebraska Hop God that I swear have been there since the beer section opened. Once it’s gone bad, the beer geeks won’t touch it. So who buys it? Maybe someone who just getting into good beer reading about Sculpin on Ratebeer and overpays for a tremendous letdown, possibly souring them on craft beer or that particular brewery forever. Who should make the call when a beer needs to be pulled? And who eats the cost?

It’s a problem of which Founder’s seems aware, and I applaud their decision to move Red’s Rye Pale Ale to a seasonal, rather than year-round. When fresh, it’s a lovely beer. But once bottled, the clock is ticking… next time I see it on the shelves in its new incarnation as 4-pack seasonl specialty, I will pick it up, take it home, and drink it immediately. I don’t have to walk past it anymore and watch a great beer get further from it’s glorious prime with each passing week.

Again, Founder’s, Victory, Troeg’s are some of our very best breweries. But by my (admittedly anecdotal) observations, they have major problems moving enough of their flagship pale ales that I can be assured of getting a fresh beer off the shelf at retailers. I’ve seen the same phenomenon in specialty bottle shops as well. The hyped seasonals go fast, the familiar standards sit. I’ve been burned too many times, and these days I won’t even take the chance on an IPA without a bottled-on date. What chance do the plethora of new year-round IPA’s from upstart breweries stand when even tested, tried brands can’t move product amid the insane variety and competition? People love to talk about the craft beer bubble, and this is a quality control issue that I see as a real threat to the continued growth of the industry.

I suspect the market will help resolve this issue over the long haul. Advances in distribution technology will help as consumers begin to demand that delicate hopped ales be kept cold end-to-end. Bottled-on dates or QR batch codes will become industry standard. The Stone Enjoy By campaign has shown a light on the issue, and proven consumers will pay for quality and freshness. And there are exceptions- Bell’s Two Hearted is very popular here and I’ve yet to see it expired.

My solution has been increasingly to support my local brewer. Is East End Big Hop or Helltown Insidious “Better” than the highly-rated Sculpin? I don’t know, but I sure prefer it from my growler a couple weeks out of the tank, rather than bottled and shipped thousands of miles. Don’t get me wrong- the week we get Hopslam in February is a highlight of a dark and dismal month, but my local breweries keep me in good suds the rest of the year.

Any other hop heads out there been burned by IPA’s past their prime? Or am I just getting too picky in my old age? Let me know if this is a problem where you live.



  1. we have the exact same issue in birmingham, and oddly enough, founders is the one i notice the most as well. i haven’t seen fresh centennial, pale, or red’s rye since they first started shipping to the state. while i hate that i can’t have it fresh all the time, i will be glad to at least see the occasional fresh red’s rye with the move to seasonal. just like you, my solution has been to drink more and more local stuff that i know is fresh.

    very glad to see a new post, by the way.

  2. At this point in craft beer’s rise, it really should be the standard for most breweries to include bottle-on dates on either beer labels or six-packs, or at the very least to do that for hoppy beers.

    I will tell you something that particularly annoys me–some breweries will have “bottled on” notes on the label, but then it’s followed by a sequence of coded numbers that doesn’t actually tell me the date. They’re labeling the product so only they can monitor how old it is.

    I’ve even noticed some have the words “bottled on,” but then nothing printed next to it. You can see it in this Left Hand Wake Up Dead label (weird example, I know):

    If you look at the bottom right of the red portion, next to the small skull, you can see “bottled on” with no date, and that’s exactly what it looks like when you find it at the store. I realize it’s not an IPA, but why print “bottled on” on the label if you’re not going to write a date next to it?

  3. You are right on the money with this. Great Lakes Burning River and any of the Maine Beer Company Pale Ales are prime examples of “ya gotta make sure it’s fresh”. Thankfully, both breweries use “best by” dates and I pay extra special attention to them because there is a HUGE difference between a fresh and not so fresh version of these beers.

  4. I think I notice it with Founders more because their bottled-on date is so prominent. So whenever I see a seasonal by them, I grab it. No questions asked.

    We’ve touched on this over the years, but it’s still a disturbing trend. If you want more people to get into craft beer, the worst thing to do is give them a beer that’s well past its prime. I’m much more careful at the store now (, having been burned so many times.

  5. Totally agree about the issue and the desire for bottled-on dates, it’s something I’ve really started to notice. Also seems to be a big issue with American barleywines. High alcohol and expensive, they tend to sit for a while, especially in the grocery store setting, and you can really feel that faded hop character… unless you really age the sucker for a few years. Drinking local is definitely a boon. Victory sixpacks may be old, but I can always count on fresh Victory when I go to the brewery!

  6. Just echoing everyone else here, but good points. If the market calls for more brews that depend on quality of freshness, it only seems like a good business idea to label better as well. Provides for more informed consumers and maybe even distributors who could catch a problem batch sitting for too long.

  7. Wow, look at the consensus in this thread. I guess “fresh IPA’s are better” isn’t the most controversial statement I’ve ever made.

    Regarding Victory and Great Lakes, I appreciate that they date their bottles but I’m a much bigger proponent of “Bottled-on Dates” than “Best-by Dates”. This weekend I looked at some Hop Wallop that had a thin coating of dust on it, and a best-by date of late 2013. I’m only interested in purchasing Hop Wallop within maybe 60 days of bottling at the most; clearly the brewer has a different concept of best-by than I do, for obvious reasons. Why not just state the bottling date, and let the consumer decide how old is too old? I’m glad Founders does it that way, even if it does at time make them a target for complaints like this, transparency is always the best policy.

  8. I’ve been burned so many times that if I can’t find a date (on an IPA) I don’t buy, period. Other styles I don’t really mind, but I demand fresh IPA so I mostly end up making them myself and if I get lucky and find something fresh at the store I’ll still pick it up, but if I find it’s more than a month and half old I won’t. I’m quite a snob I guess. Oh well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s